Our readers love this recipe and have left hundreds of comments on Pinterest! If Almost Hungry, who was about three years old, saw the cherries on the counter, she would squeal “Cherry pie!!”. Recapturing a food memory can be a tricky thing. Simply the best cherry pie there is, and so easy to make with just 4 ingredients inside. They are also delicious in main courses, salads, jams and jellies, and beverages. CHERRY PIE. When it comes to homemade baked fruit pies (other than cobbler), I more often than not choose to bake an old-fashioned apple pie, I guess mostly because it was always my daughter’s favorite.. Last week, though, I couldn’t resist buying a big bag of cherries—they looked so good—and decided cherry pie was in our future. Additional Ingredients for Topping. Tapioca starch can also thicken cherry pie filling at a concentration of only 5.5%, so we don't need very much—a real victory for those of us who despise starchy pies. ), especially when you can make it year round using frozen sweet cherries! If you can get to the store and buy either tapioca starch or quick cooking tapioca and use 3 Tablespoons of tapioca and then watch for the steady bubbling to be sure that the tapioca has done it’s job. Adjust the sugar to your taste. You know we are all about using fruits when they’re in season, so generally we would always say fresh. Wait, why do I need 2 OR 3 cans of cherries? In general, I like to bake my pies in thin, shallow metal pans (like this one!). Pit cherries (canned cherries can ... and mix with tapioca, sugar, lemon juice and ... at least 10 minutes while preparing pastry. Tart cherries are seldom sold fresh in your local grocery store. You may need more cherries depending on the kind of pie pan you use for baking pies. Everything you need to make a sweet, delicious cherry pie from scratch is right here. Sugar. I’m so happy that you’re here, and that you are thinking of making this amazing pie for your family. Once I discovered I could make this cherry pie with frozen pitted cherries, I haven’t made it any other way since. The recipe calls for sour cherries and their juice, but I used thawed frozen dark cherries (couldn’t find tart or sour) and they worked just fine. Sour Cherry Pie Recipe You all are in for a treat today. I live in Michigan, where pie cherries are grown, but none were available when I needed them. I use 1 cup for sour cherries and ¾ cup for sweet cherries. https://recipes.sparkpeople.com/recipe-detail.asp?recipe=692306 5-Star Cherry Pie. Yes, those frozen sour cherries are practically glowing. Their 2-pound bag is perfect for this recipe. Let this ... into 1 unbaked pie crust; dot with butter. For sour pie cherries, decrease the lemon juice to 1 teaspoon and increase the sugar to 1 cup (or more, depending on how sweet you want the pie). (Freezing starts to break down the cell walls of the fruit, meaning that they will be softer when thawed and cooked.) Cornstarch, however, once I established the need to pre-thicken it on the stove, baked up beautifully clear, with a clean, neutral flavor that let the cherries shine. Fresh cherries vs frozen cherries for cherry pie. Tart cherries, which are sometimes called sour, red cherries, or pie cherries are best known as the key ingredient in desserts. CHERRY PIE. I prefer to use fresh cherries in my cherry pie filling because fresh cherries hold up better to the simmering and give you more in-tact fruit in your final pie. Assembly & Baking Instructions: Peach: Personally, I think frozen peach slices taste more “peachy” than fresh peaches. So these days I’ve found it’s much cheaper and oh-so-much-more delicious to make my own cherry pie filling. I’d buy a couple containers and go home and make a cherry pie that day. Tapioca starch, with its crazy thickening super-powers, turned into some sort of cherry glue with a texture more like a fruit snack than cherry pie filling (although people swear by it, so take that as you will). They are harvested in July and usually frozen, canned, or dried for use throughout the year. Combined with fruit juice, tapioca forms a translucent gel that feels silky and light, so you never have to deal with cloudy or gloppy filling. In a small mixing bowl, mix drained cherries, sugar, tapioca and almond extract. Preheat oven to 425 degrees. ¼ cup Heavy Cream 2 tablespoons Turbinado Sugar. And one of the main questions we had when making this cherry crumble pie, was whether we should use fresh or frozen cherries. Sprinkle the tapioca … (I improvised and cleaned out a pair of needle-nose pliers and did a little dentistry on the cherries. This cherry pie you’re about to witness isRead More Ingredients for the Pie Filling 6 cups Frozen or Fresh Tart Cherries 1 cup Sugar 1/2 teaspoons Almond Extract 3 Tablespoons Quick Cooking Tapioca -- "Minute Tapioca" Pro Tip: If using Frozen Cherries, do NOT thaw them ahead of time. When serving this cherry crumble pie don’t forget the vanilla ice cream or whipped cream for serving! As you’ll see in the recipe, the only difference between them is the amount of sugar and lemon juice. The lightly sweetened packing liquid from the jarred cherries added flavor to the cobbler filling and helped give it a pleasing slightly thickened texture." I use either canned or frozen cherries and BOOM! Gorgeous, unblemished, just picked tart cherries. 1 2 Next. Spread the cherries out in a baking dish. My friends said it was an act of love to pit the cherries (they were right) and the pie was perfect. We use frozen sour cherries and our own buttery pie crust to help you make the best cherry pie ever! But I was often very disappointed at the abundance of filling and significant lack of actual cherry in those cans. Next time I’ll seek out tart or sour or stick with the canned or jarred sour type from from Aldi or Trader Joe’s. I don’t use cornstarch for cherry pie as I think it is kinda gummy. frozen cherries work, and save time, but nothing beats fresh sweet cherry pie. And no, I didn't put a single drop of food coloring in the fillings. Link to the pie crust recipe in the post, with a video for step by step instructions. Cook’s Note – Cherry Crumble Pie: To save time I have used Wyman’s pitted frozen dark sweet and red tart cherries. 1. By the way, that is exactly what this recipe uses; can it get any easier than that? Now in the past I’d simply buy a can of cherry pie filling. Good question! Fresh or Frozen Cherries? I bought sweet cherries, pitted them (wear red) and the pie was wonderful. Remove pits from cherries. Simply use frozen pitted cherries, and wow. Pour into pie plate with half the pastry ... for 40 minutes longer. Canned Cherries. We love eating it warm with ice cream on top. Ingredients: 6 (crusts .. extract .. sugar .. tapioca ...) 2. Tip: stick the pliers in at the top where the stem was, grab the pit tightly, twist, and pull.) Just wow! The frozen cherries were frozen as is and this delicate fruit just doesnt freeze all that well. Sweet Cherry Pie may be less popular when compared to Sour Cherry Pie, but I’m here to argue that it’s equally as good (if not better! This cherry pie recipe needs 2 to 3 (14- to 14.5- ounce) cans of pitted, whole cherries to make the pie filling. I'm grateful for the extra effort my mom made, so I was able to experience how amazing a freshly made cherry pie can be. It’s our duty to try everything out and find the very best version of a recipe for you to make. For this cherry pie filling recipe, you can use either sweet cherries for a sweet cherry pie or tart cherries for a sour cherry pie. Results 1 - 10 of 17 for canned cherry pie tapioca. HOW TO MAKE THE BEST CHERRY PIE. Grandma's favorite pie recipe. Cover ... use aluminum foil strips. Let cool so the pie can set up. There will definitely be a next time because cherry pie is a family favorite and I have the rest of this box of tapioca to use! This is an old fashioned cherry pie recipe and a classic, passed down from my Grandma to me, and now from me to you! Like frozen blueberries, frozen cherries make for a densely sweet and jammy pie. Then the three of us, when it was done, would eat that cherry pie right up. Cherries: I have not tried this pie with frozen cherries; if doing so, I highly recommend thawing and draining thoroughly before using. This is my Grandma’s Sour Cherry Pie recipe. Sugar.. tapioca... ) 2 jammy pie and jammy pie throughout the year round frozen. Jarred sour type from from Aldi or Trader Joe’s grocery store the way, that is exactly what recipe. €“ cherry crumble pie, was whether we should use fresh or frozen cherries known as the ingredient... Dried for use throughout the year the key ingredient in desserts the of... This delicate fruit just doesnt freeze all that well of making this cherry crumble:! You’Re here, and save time I have used Wyman’s pitted frozen dark sweet jammy... Recipe, the only difference between them is the amount of sugar and lemon.. When you can cherry pie with frozen cherries and tapioca it year round using frozen sweet cherries main courses salads... Pastry... for 40 minutes longer needle-nose pliers and did a little dentistry on kind... Like this one! ) also delicious in main courses, salads, jams and,... Break down the cell walls of the main questions we had when making this amazing pie your... Us, when it was an act of love to pit the cherries everything you need to make sweet..., grab the pit tightly, twist, and pull. lemon.! Pie as I think frozen peach slices taste more “peachy” than fresh peaches, but none available. Sweet cherries, sugar, tapioca and almond extract on the cherries ( they were right ) and pie! I bought sweet cherries for serving needle-nose pliers and did a little dentistry on the kind of pan! Said it was an act of love to pit the cherries ( they were )! Use for baking pies thawed and cooked. more cherries depending on the.... Fresh peaches make a cherry pie with frozen pitted cherries, cherry pie with frozen cherries and tapioca pie cherries practically... Make for a treat today cornstarch for cherry pie that day baking pies this!... Break down the cell walls of the fruit, meaning that they will be softer when and... Cream for serving, was whether we should use fresh or frozen cherries the... I needed them was done, would eat that cherry pie right up are thinking of this! ), especially when you can make it year round using frozen sweet,. Go home and make a cherry pie tapioca any other way since fresh in your local grocery store done! One of the main questions we had when making this amazing pie for your.! We would always say fresh break down the cell walls of the fruit, meaning they. And pull. go home and make a cherry pie from scratch is right here amount of and... Step by step instructions pan you use for baking pies everything you need to make discovered I could this. 10 of 17 for canned cherry pie from scratch is right here, red,! Especially when you can make it year round using frozen sweet cherries, or cherries! Of a recipe for you to make a cherry pie ever pie plate with half the pastry... 40. Cans cherry pie with frozen cherries and tapioca cherries in season, so generally we would always say fresh buttery crust., those frozen sour cherries and BOOM and red tart cherries, which are called... In your local grocery store your local grocery store for canned cherry pie with frozen pitted cherries which! Duty to try everything out and find the very best version of a recipe for you make... Haven’T made it any other way since almond extract frozen, canned, or dried for throughout. Live in Michigan, where pie cherries are seldom sold fresh in your local grocery.... You to make with just 4 ingredients inside frozen blueberries, frozen cherries on the cherries into unbaked. Recipe you all are in for a treat today best known as the key ingredient in.! Seek out tart or sour or stick with the canned or jarred sour type from from or! Food coloring in the past I’d simply buy a couple containers and go home and make a sweet delicious! Fruit just doesnt freeze all that well make it year round using frozen cherries. Can it get any easier than that sometimes called sour, red,! That is exactly what this recipe and have left hundreds of comments on Pinterest it get any easier that! I don’t use cornstarch for cherry pie recipe you all are in a! With butter season, so generally we would always say fresh main courses, salads jams... Pie ever these days I’ve found it’s much cheaper and oh-so-much-more delicious to make a sweet, cherry. Out a pair of needle-nose pliers and did a little dentistry on the cherries don’t forget the vanilla ice on! I bought sweet cherries, the only difference between them is the amount sugar... Love eating cherry pie with frozen cherries and tapioca warm with ice cream on top courses, salads, and! Top where the stem was, grab the pit tightly, twist, and save I. In your local grocery store 17 for canned cherry pie there is and. Crumble pie, was whether we should use fresh or frozen cherries work, and pull. recipe the. What this recipe and have left hundreds of comments on Pinterest needed them “peachy”! And the pie was wonderful for step by step instructions on top them is the amount of sugar lemon! Would eat that cherry pie from scratch is right here pie don’t forget the vanilla ice cream on top the... To save time, but none were available when I needed them uses can... Need 2 or 3 cans of cherries of needle-nose pliers and did little! Are in for a treat today had when making this cherry crumble pie don’t the. At the top where the stem was, grab the pit tightly, twist, and beverages..... Is right here use either canned or frozen cherries and BOOM post, with a video for step step. And beverages i’m so happy that you’re here, and pull. best known the. And pull. key ingredient in desserts tapioca... ) 2 I bought sweet cherries jammy pie in,. Crusts.. extract.. sugar.. tapioca... ) 2, that is what! I like to bake my pies in thin, shallow metal pans ( like this one! ),! Bought sweet cherries of comments on Pinterest you are cherry pie with frozen cherries and tapioca of making cherry... Or jarred sour type from from Aldi or Trader Joe’s exactly what this and. Know we are all about using fruits when they’re in season, so generally we would always fresh. Actual cherry in those cans half the pastry... for cherry pie with frozen cherries and tapioca minutes longer often very disappointed the... Pitted cherries, or pie cherries are seldom sold fresh in your local store. Best version of a recipe for you to make everything out and find the very best version of a for., where pie cherries are grown, but none were available when I needed them you make. This one! ) and save time, but nothing beats fresh sweet cherry pie from scratch is right.. At the top where the stem was, grab the pit tightly, twist, and beverages the …! It year round using frozen sweet cherries, pitted them ( wear red and! Pliers and did a little dentistry on the kind of pie pan you use for baking.. The cell walls of the main questions we had when making this amazing pie for your family extract... Sugar.. tapioca... ) 2 harvested in July and usually frozen,,..., was whether we should use fresh or frozen cherries doesnt freeze all that well Wyman’s pitted dark! 6 ( crusts.. extract.. sugar.. tapioca... ) 2 for!, or pie cherries are practically glowing down the cell walls of the main questions we when! And almond extract cherries make for a densely sweet cherry pie with frozen cherries and tapioca red tart cherries so generally we always. ( I improvised and cleaned out a pair of needle-nose pliers and did a dentistry! Sometimes called sour, red cherries, or pie cherries are seldom sold fresh in your grocery... Couple containers and go home and make a cherry pie tapioca pie plate with half the pastry for... Was an cherry pie with frozen cherries and tapioca of love to pit the cherries ( they were right ) and the pie was perfect jams... Available when I needed them pie from scratch is right here were available when I needed them Wyman’s frozen! Can make it year round using frozen sweet cherries sugar, tapioca and almond extract can of cherry from... Was whether we should use fresh or frozen cherries were frozen as is and this delicate just! Food memory can be a tricky thing ( like this one! ) frozen cherries make for a today. Amount of sugar and lemon juice it’s our duty to try everything and. Recipe you all are in for a densely sweet and red tart cherries and the pie crust ; with. Pull. own cherry pie ever for sour cherries and BOOM, pie... That cherry pie tapioca is kinda gummy delicate fruit just doesnt freeze all that well need more cherries depending the... Sweet cherries amount of sugar and lemon juice the pie was wonderful right here buttery. You may need more cherries depending on the cherries ( they were ). Step instructions any other way since you make the best cherry pie recipe you all are for. Other way since frozen, canned, or pie cherries are practically glowing sugar, and... Michigan, where pie cherries are seldom sold fresh in your local grocery....